Monday, February 15, 2010

Article 4- Carol Tell

This article discusses a conversation with another author, Jane M. Healy, about her article. Healy's article focuses on the pros and cons of technology on children and how it has developed over the years. The main point in the introduction of this article talked about how "technology, no matter how advanced it becomes, does not have the same weight as good teachers, small classes, and challenging curriculum". I agree with this quote; I think nothing can replace those things. This is a good point to make because our world is technology obsessed and always looking for the newest and greatest thing. If we lose focus on what the cornerstone of the classroom is, there could be major problems later on the road. Good teaching does not fail--technology fails us all the time. We as teachers can use technology for many different great purposes in our teaching, but cannot forget the cornerstones of teaching. I also liked how she discussed that it is the teachers obligation to get caught up on what the students are using in their studies and how it is beneficial to their work. Many teachers never get caught up on what their students are learning or using technology-wise. I cannot even begin to count the number of teachers I have had that did not know anything about the technology they and we were using and could hardly get through the day. These points, including many others, in her article are very important for teachers to consider and take into account.

6 comments:

  1. Linds-
    Good reflection on the article- I especially liked your point about "how good teaching does not fail--technology fails us all the time". SO TRUE! Technology is constantly changing, people are constantly changing their programs, we are always hearing about how certain things that we were told were soooo good for our children, actually affect them in a negative way. We can't always rely on technology, not if we want our children to be successful. The article talks about how if we were good educators, we would make an effort to understand our curriculum, the needs of our students and what works best for them, which I thought to be very true. I was in so many classes growing up where teachers knew NOTHING about technology, and we went the "old school" way of learning. It has worked for many years, why do we need to make such a huge change without knowing the consequences.
    Nice blog girl!
    <3

    ReplyDelete
  2. MEEEland-
    I definitely agree with you-we are technologically obsessed in this culture and technology can't ever replace a truly good curriculum. I loved what you said "good teaching does not fail". I think this is something we will have to remember when our school districts push for more use of technology. We must ask ourselves if we can teacher better than the technology and if so, why should we use it?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Linds, your blog is exactly what I wrote my blog on! I really feel strongly about the fact that technology cannot replace actual teaching! Good teachers are PEOPLE, not computers. Although computers can enhance learning..we probably shouldn't depend on them to do our jobs.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Lindsey -
    Like your other comments, I felt similarly as you in your blog. I don't think anyone could argue that computers are as good as teachers. Well, not all teachers, but good ones:)
    I thought you said this point clearly when you said that good teaching never fails, but technology fails us all the time. This is so true!
    Using technology in the classroom is completely dependent on that technology working and we all know that this is not always the case. We should never depend on technology alone. If a kid doesn't understand a concept, they cannot ask a computer and get an answer like a teacher could provide. I guess that's obvious...
    Before we start using technology or programs in the classroom we should really think about how necessary it is.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Lindsey,
    I definitely agree with you about how technology cannot replace a good teacher with a solid curriculum. That is one of the points that I felt was most powerful in this article. It is also very true that being technology obsessed now may lead to troubles down the road. It is interesting how many schools are not thinking of this because right now it is more important to have computers in every classroom. I really like how you said that good teaching does not fail, but technology does. That is a very good point; we cannot rely on something that is unreliable. Also, we must be conscious of what our students are using and how we can use technology in an effective and appropriate manner.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think you chose a very good quote from this article to sum the whole thing up. That is the same message I got; technology can not replace good teaching. I really like your comment about how good teaching does not fail but technology does. Every one who's ever regularly used some form of technology (all of us) I'm sure can tell you at least one nightmare story from there past about a time when technology has failed them at exactly the wrong time.

    ReplyDelete